Beyond Hogwarts

<Latest Articles
Comments Index
Save Last On

Search Beyond Hogwarts:

Reference Desk:
Beyond Hogwarts FAQ
Wizard to Muggle Currency Converter
Harry Potter Spelling Reference

Final Deathly Hallows Debates: Who Lives and Who Dies?

We know for sure that some characters are going to die in Deathly Hallows. Last year in an interview, J.K. Rowling said that two characters die who she had not originally thought would die in the end of the story. That means at least two characters die, but probably more. And that's probably not counting Harry and/or Voldemort. So who lives and who dies? Tell us who you think will die, and more importantly, why you think so.

Pages:  <<  <  34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 ...  >  >>

Reader Comments: (Page 44)

Harry tries to save Ron, when sadly he is ed by Voldemort, then Hermione s too. Now Voldemorts power is getting to strong from obsorbing their power. Harry s himself to destroy Lord Voldemort, who then instantly s from the power draining that Harry held. Harry meets his Ron and Hermione in the ly Hallows.

Posted by Mike on July 13, 2007 11:40 PM

It's porobably going to be Harry and Voldemort. I think, that they are both unbalancing the scale beetween good and bad so strong, i think it'll be them.
After all. J.K. ed everyones favourite...

Posted by William from Macclesfield on July 14, 2007 01:28 AM

First things first. Snape , whether it be through saving Harry's life to repay the life to James or some other means, he . Second, in GoF, Dumbledore says something about the 'liasons between magical schools would be more important than ever.' This should come into play in DH. After all, there is still Fleur and Krum, and I think Krum still likes Hermione. So Krum could protecting her, and/or Bill could protecting Fleur. Also, with Bellatrix. I think Harry and/or Neville get revenge for what she's done. Then there's Voldemort and Harry. One obviously , but it's more likely that both . JK has already said that would be a way to off the merchandising, which would be useless to me, after all, she'll have to off all the girls to stop the merchandising (If she doesn't I'm going to be writing a 'Harry's Illegitimate Child' series). Anyways, Harry is more than likely the last Horcrux, I mean why would JK word the following quote like this: "Voldemort put a bit of himself in me?" Harry said, thunderstruck. "It certainly seems so." It's a big hint towards it, and harry should himself to Voldemort. Also, I think that Sirius come back, after all didn't Luna say 'Things that you lose always have a way of coming back to you, even in the most unexpected ways.', or was that just the movie? I don't know. My brain's hurting to try and think if that was from the book. Anyways, Sirius come back and do something of importance. Perhaps Vold's snake.

Also, with the whole thing about JK saying that Dumb won't pull a Gandalf isn't of too much importance, in my opinion. Gandalf d and came back to life, and right now I strongly believe that he is alive, so he couldn't pull a Gandalf in that situation. But if he is alive, he could easily pull a Boromir and save a bunch of people from Eaters.

Anyways, that's my theory for now. I'm off to watch OotP for the 5th time, BTW, what did you guys think of OotP? I absolutely love Evanna in that movie. I LOVE HER. I hope she doesn't get ed off in DH. I'll cry.

Posted by Curtis on July 14, 2007 03:03 AM

I think Voldemort in the form of Tom Riddle.

Posted by usman from manama , Bahrain on July 14, 2007 03:35 AM

I think Harry is the last Horcrux, and he either sacrifice himself so Ron or Hermione can Voldemort OR somehow destroy Voldemort's body, then ask Ron or Hermione to him, saying it's the only way to prevent him from coming back.
I also think that Dumbledore turned into a phoenix and be with Harry in his last battle with Voldemort. It be sad to see Harry , but I believe it's the only way.

Posted by Abbye Spencer on July 14, 2007 06:37 AM

I think that Ron aswell as Neville. Before Neville s he avenge his parents by ing Bellatrix. Snape assist in ing Voldemort, and succeed Dumbledore as the headmaster of Hogwarts. I also think Harry may too.

Posted by Ejaaz Ousmand on July 14, 2007 08:29 AM

I honestly, honestly, HONESTLY think that out of the Eaters, Bellatrix, Snape and Lucius/Narcissa . I think Harry Bellatrix, because of what happened to Sirius, Snape because he ed Dumbledore, and Lucius/Narcissa to protect their son, Draco.

I also think that Harry's scar is not a horcrux. Seriously, it's not possible. Would Voldemort honestly make Harry a horcrux, and him? Voldemort wouldn't make a horcrux and try to destroy it... and when would Voldemort get another chance to make the scar or Harry a horcrux? There's something to think about!

As for Hogwarts, it'll re-open, hands down.

Peter Pettigrew... He owes his like to Harry... so, I hope something is done..

As for the trio, I think Hermione , and Ron and Harry live.

Posted by Nick from Brampton, Ontario on July 14, 2007 10:29 AM

matthew, you are totally right about rowling!

about the horcrux guys... harry or his scar cannot be a horcrux. Because when he is, the prophecy cannot be fulfilled. harry cannot live if he wants to voldermort is his scar is a horcrux. And the prophecy says that one has to the other...

Posted by m van treijeN from rotterdam. the netherlands on July 14, 2007 11:31 AM

i think that voldemort most definatly , he has to. as we learned in hp6 Voldy likes to people who are close to harry wich makes me think that the trio not come out as a trio, i just hope im wrong.
i think snape because he didnt have the heart to do something voldemort told him to do, so he ed him. someone from the order , or several but i dont know who. thats a fact, given all the peole who d last time.
i think that harry be the last horcrux, but then he would have to himself and who would voldy?(the prophecy from hpootp)this makes me think that harry but again, who would voldy?
i also think draco or suffer some other severe punishment sinse he didnt dumbldore.or lucius may protecting him, but lucius doesnt strike me as the unselfish type.
whoever jk s i hope its not harry, ron, hermione,hagrid,lupin,luna,any of the Weasly's, mcgonagall,tonks, mad-eye,or cho. but i REALLY doubt i'll be that lucky. i was really upset when sirius d, he was my favorite. but oh well, thats just what i think.

Posted by sheyanne from honolulu, hawaii on July 14, 2007 12:59 PM

Honestly, I think that at least a few of the following people :

1.Harry Potter - As much as I don't want Harry to , I think it's sort of a destiny of his. (just like the prophecy) To me it's a little obvious Harry .

2.maybe Voldemort? - Maybe Harry does Voldemort but afterword is ed by someone else.

3.Peter Pettigrew - Ever since The Prisoner of Azkaban in which Harry spared his life, Peter Pettigrew has a to Harry. I think he might do something for Harry and in the process, .

4.Ginny Weasley - At the end of The Half-Blood Prince, Ginny wanted to go with Harry to the 'ly Hallows'. Harry said no because he remembered that In his 2nd year, Voldemort posessed Ginny's body just because she was the sister of Harry's best friend. Harry thought that if Voldemort did that because she was the SISTER of his best friend, what would happen to her if she was his GIRLFRIEND? Ginny said she didn't care, but Harry broke up with her anyways. I think that Ginny follow Harry to the ly Hallows despite of what Harry said because she likes him so much. I also think it would be very sweet if Harry and Ginny together.

5.Hermione Granger? - I'm not quite sure about Hermione, but in the books i think Hermione has started to like either Harry or Ron (i can't quite tell though). If she does like Harry then maybe she trying to help defend Harry. If not, then I have no clue.

And also, to all of you who think Harry or his scar is a horcrux, that isn't possible because Harry is a living person and has thoughts of his own. You can't put a horcrux in someone. You can posess them though, but as we found out in th 5th book Harry isn't being posessed by Voldemort.

Posted by Heather on July 14, 2007 1:14 PM

I'm guessing Snape and Hagrid , though I don't have any great reasons other than instinct. I don't want Voldy to , I want him to be stripped completely powerless and left to howel in the forests of Albania forever. I'd be satisfied if it wasn't Albania, but the Chamber of Secrets-- He and Myrtle could hang out. Put Myrtle in charge.

If Harry does , I think he may somehow be ressurected since JKR would not answer any questions about religious content in the books until after bk 7 is completed-- she said it would give too much away. (That could mean a sacrifice is on the table also).

I note that scar is no longer the last word of book 7, though it was for 15 years in the plannning. My idea about the scar is really very simple: Lily's proctection resides in Harry's blood. The curse Voldy put on Harry (whether the AK or some other type of ing curse required in the making of a Horcrux) could not penetrate his blood, and it's stopped on his forehead. If it's not a fully developed horcrux there's /something/ of Voldy in there, a part of his soul. (That would mean the whole seven books are a parenthesis between the night at Godric's Hollow and the final outcome.) I had pictured the last sentence reading something like this: Never again was there any trace of the lightening bolt scar. (That's not very good, but you get the idea). Another option is that Voldy gets completely absorbed into the scar and is trapped there- forever, perhaps. That's really horrific, though.

There's a lot of questions about Godric's Hollow one of which is: If Peter Pettrigrew was the Secret Keeper, how did Hagrid find Harry? I believe that either Dumbledore or Hagrid was a secret keeper as to Harry's location /OR/ one of them was some type of guardian over Harry, in addition to Peter Pettrigrew being the secret keeper for the Potters. If it was Dumbledore, he told Hagrid where to find Harry.

In recent days we have learned that Bellatrix is important (I'm really pulling for Neville to take her out) and JKR told David Yates he'd better not take Kreacher out of the OOTP film, so we can look for them to play significant roles in DH.

I hated Sirius . His whole like was tragic on a Shakespearean scale. Too sad. Dumbledore was just awful too, but at least he had a full life. Harry has to marry Ginny and they have somewhere between 5 and 9 kids. He'll have the family he always wanted.(He slayed the 'dragon' for Ginny, with a sword, they have to have their 'happily ever after!') Ron and Hermione (who be editor of the Daily Prophet of chief resident at St. Mungos) live just down the street. Neville be either a hogwarts teacher or the Minister of Magic and Fred and George be richer than the Malfoys. I be most vehemently upset if any of them .

Posted by JM from varies on July 14, 2007 1:19 PM

for one i do not think harry . as the prophecy said in ootp, harry has to voldemort or voldemort has to harry. i think voldemort dso unless someone else s harry he wont .
i hope ron and hermione dont , but voldy likes to people close to harry, so there is a chance that they might.

Posted by acara from miami,fl on July 14, 2007 1:25 PM

Pages:  <<  <  34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 ...  >  >>

Latest Discussions | Comments | The Septology | Harry's World | Harry Potter Movies | FAQ is not affiliated with or approved by
Scholastic Books, Bloomsbury, Warner Bros., or J.K. Rowling
Original Content Copyright © 2006-2009 David Haber, All Rights Reserved